A Butler County, Ohio jury has awarded $12.5 million in the wrongful death of Janice Darlene Combs, an 83-year-old blind resident who suffered a catastrophic brain bleed after she was allegedly dropped during a transfer at Chesterwood Village nursing home in West Chester. The verdict, returned May 14, 2026 in the Butler County Court of Common Pleas, included $11 million in compensatory damages and $1.5 million in punitive damages. The jury found unanimously that the facility and its corporate operators breached the standard of care and violated Ohio's Nursing Home Residents' Bill of Rights. Plaintiff attorney William B. Eadie of Eadie Law: Nursing Home Injury Lawyers represented the Estate of Janice Combs.
Case at a Glance
- Verdict: $12.5 million ($11 million compensatory, $1.5 million punitive)
- Case Type: Wrongful death / nursing home negligence
- Court: Butler County Court of Common Pleas, Ohio (Judge Daniel E. Haughey)
- Verdict Date: May 14, 2026
- Plaintiff: Estate of Janice Darlene Combs (Rita Combs-Jordan, daughter and estate representative)
- Defendant: Chesterwood Village (Chesterwood Nursing Care, Ltd.) and corporate operators
- Plaintiff Attorney: William B. Eadie, Eadie Law: Nursing Home Injury Lawyers
- Docket: CV 2024 06 1161
What Happened to Janice Combs?
Janice Combs was admitted to Chesterwood Village in June 2023 for short-term rehabilitation after a fall down the stairs at her home, where she had been living independently despite being blind. According to court records, within about two hours of returning to the facility from a hospital evaluation, Combs sustained a fall while in the nursing home's care.
When West Chester Township Fire Department paramedics arrived, they reported finding Combs with an injury to the back of her head and blood in her room. The lawsuit alleged she had been dropped by nursing staff while being transferred from her wheelchair to her bed, an incident the plaintiff said the facility failed to document.
Combs was taken to a hospital and diagnosed with a catastrophic brain bleed. She became dependent on a ventilator and remained bedbound until her death in March 2024, nearly ten months after the fall.
Why Did the Jury Side with the Plaintiff?
The jury answered every interrogatory in favor of the Estate of Janice Combs. It found that the defendants breached the standard of care, that the breach proximately caused her injuries and death, and that the facility violated Ohio's Nursing Home Residents' Bill of Rights.
A central issue at trial was the discrepancy between the nursing home's records and the EMS run report describing how and where Combs was injured. The plaintiff argued that the facility failed to document the drop and the resulting head injury, leaving paramedics to piece together what happened from the scene.
"Families place their loved ones in nursing homes trusting they will be kept safe, and trusting that the truth will be told if something goes wrong," said William B. Eadie, lead attorney for the estate.
How the $12.5 Million Award Breaks Down
The nine-day trial produced a compensatory award of $11 million, which the jury divided into $1 million for survivorship, $8 million for wrongful death, and $2 million for the violations of the Nursing Home Residents' Bill of Rights. The jury added $1.5 million in punitive damages, exceeding the $1 million in punitive damages the plaintiff had requested.
Punitive damages are reserved for conduct a jury finds especially blameworthy, beyond ordinary negligence. The award signals that jurors viewed the facility's handling of the incident, including the documentation failures, as warranting punishment and not just compensation.
For the family, the verdict carried meaning beyond the dollar figure. "My mom was part of our life, part of the thread, and she was the glue that held it together," said Rita Combs-Jordan, Combs' daughter and the estate's representative.
What the Verdict Signals for Ohio Nursing Home Cases
The defendants are expected to pursue post-trial motions and a possible appeal, so the award is not yet final. Even so, the result stands among the more substantial nursing home negligence verdicts in Ohio, combining a full compensatory award with punitive damages and a finding under the state's Residents' Bill of Rights.
For plaintiff attorneys, the case illustrates how documentation gaps, when contrasted against independent records like an EMS run report, can anchor a nursing home negligence claim.
Verdicts like this one deserve to be seen. Major Verdict is the only platform where plaintiff attorneys can publicly display their trial results and settlements, for free. Create your profile today and let your record speak for itself.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What were the punitive damages in the Chesterwood Village verdict?
The jury awarded $1.5 million in punitive damages on top of $11 million in compensatory damages, for a total of $12.5 million. Punitive damages are meant to punish conduct a jury finds especially blameworthy, and here the amount exceeded the $1 million the plaintiff had requested.
Q: What is Ohio's Nursing Home Residents' Bill of Rights?
It is a set of legal protections under Ohio law guaranteeing nursing home residents rights such as safe care, dignity, and adequate supervision. In this case, the jury awarded $2 million specifically for the facility's violations of those rights, separate from the wrongful death and survivorship damages.
Q: Is the $12.5 million verdict final?
Not yet. The defendants are expected to pursue post-trial motions and a possible appeal, which can alter or delay payment of a jury award. A verdict becomes final only after those challenges are resolved.
NOT FOR REPRINT
© 2026 Major Verdict, LLC. All rights reserved. For more information visit our reuse and editorial standards information.
