A Florida jury awarded nearly $4 million to a 30-year-old mother of three after she slipped on liquid in a Publix Super Markets beverage aisle, with the jury finding the grocery chain 100% responsible for the injuries that followed.
The verdict, returned in Osceola County following a six-day trial, came after Publix's last settlement offer stood at just $600,000.
What Happened in the Publix Store
On June 5, 2023, Victoria Marcano slipped on liquid in the beverage aisle of a Publix location. Evidence presented at trial showed that Publix employees had already cleaned liquid from the same area before her fall, a fact that proved significant in the jury's assessment of the grocer's responsibility.
The case was filed in Osceola County as Victoria Marcano v. Publix Super Markets, Inc., Case No. 2024-CA-001128.
Three Surgeries and a Long Road Ahead
The injuries Marcano sustained were serious. She underwent three spinal surgeries: one on her neck and two on her back, with additional surgeries anticipated.
Marcano was 30 years old and raising three children at the time of the incident. Her attorneys presented evidence of the long-term impact the injuries had on her life and her ability to care for her family.
Publix's Defense and the Jury's Answer
Publix denied liability throughout the litigation and argued that Marcano was not injured as a result of the fall. The defense went further, attempting to attribute her spinal injuries to complaints related to carrying her children in the months before the incident.
The jury rejected both arguments entirely. Rather than assign partial fault, jurors found Publix 100% responsible and awarded $3,967,000 in damages, more than six times the company's pre-trial settlement offer of $600,000.
The Legal Team: Rubenstein Law
The plaintiff was represented by Nicholas T. Smith, who served as first-chair trial attorney, alongside trial attorney Dayna Nilsen and senior partner Raul E. Garcia Jr., all of Rubenstein Law.
After the verdict, Garcia Jr. commented that the jury listened to the evidence and held Publix accountable. He described Marcano as a young mother raising three children, already through three surgeries with more expected, and said the team was pleased to have secured the outcome she deserved.
The legal team noted the verdict underscores the importance of holding property owners to account when hazardous conditions go unaddressed despite known risk.
What This Verdict Signals for Premises Liability Cases
Slip and fall cases at major retail chains are often met with aggressive defenses and low settlement offers. This result illustrates a few things worth noting:
- Prior notice matters. The evidence that Publix employees had cleaned the same area before Marcano's fall was central to establishing that the hazard was known, or should have been known, and not corrected.
- Jury skepticism of "blame the plaintiff" defenses. Attributing a plaintiff's spinal injuries to childcare activities is a common defense tactic. Here, it did not resonate with the jury.
- Settlement offers can be dramatically low. The gap between Publix's $600,000 offer and the $3,967,000 verdict is a reminder that pre-trial offers don't always reflect a case's full value at trial.
Plaintiff attorneys handling premises liability cases in Florida can browse verdicts and connect with attorneys who have taken these cases to trial at Major Verdict.
Explore Florida Personal Injury Verdicts
If you were injured at a grocery store or retail location in Florida, results like this one reflect what juries are willing to award when negligence is proven. Understanding verdict history in your state can help you evaluate your options.
Explore Florida personal injury verdicts and public resources on Major Verdict, or browse attorney profiles to find a plaintiff lawyer with a verified track record at trial.
Plaintiff attorneys: Major Verdict is where you display your trial results publicly: verdicts, settlements, and the stories behind them. A free profile takes minutes to set up.
